01
Trades arrive on their own
MetaTrader 4 and 5, cTrader, TradeLocker, TopstepX, Match-Trader, DXtrade, Tradovate and NinjaTrader sync automatically. Everedge lists eleven platforms and every one of them is a CSV export you perform yourself.
Comparison
Consistry vs My Prop Journal: live rules, or deep retrospective analysis
First, a fact worth knowing before you compare anything: mypropjournal.com now redirects to everedge.ai. The site there never mentions the old name, so treat this as the destination the domain points to rather than a confirmed rebrand — but it is where you land, and it is what this page compares against.
Everedge is a serious analytical tool. Its Edge Discovery grades your setups A+ through D on statistical expectancy and ties position sizing to the grade, its AI coach can search your journal semantically, and its payout accounting tracks what you actually withdrew net of profit split against what your challenge attempts cost. That last one is genuinely rare. The catch for prop traders is that everything reaches it by CSV or by hand.
TL;DR: Everedge has the deeper AI analysis and the best payout ROI accounting; it has no automatic broker sync at all, no free tier, and costs $39 to $75 a month. Consistry syncs eight platforms live, enforces verified firm rules before the trade, and starts free.
Quick comparison
| Consistry | My Prop Journal (now Everedge) | |
|---|---|---|
| Broker auto-sync | 8 platforms, automatic | CSV upload or manual entry only |
| Live drawdown monitoring | Daily, max, trailing — from live equity | Post-import only, by design |
| Pre-trade rule check | GREEN / YELLOW / RED before entry | Retrospective analysis |
| Firm rules pre-filled | 20 firms, 26 programs, weekly verified | ~10 firms named, count not published |
| AI depth | Plan, chat, weekly analysis, pre-trade check | AI coach, semantic search, model choice |
| Expectancy grading of setups | Per-setup stats and behavioral leaks | A+ to D grades tied to position sizing |
| Payout & ROI accounting | Fees and payouts across firms | Withdrawals net of split vs account costs |
| News-restriction enforcement | Firm's own window, enforced | No news or calendar feature |
| Native mobile apps | iOS and Android | Not mentioned on their site |
| Free tier | Unlimited trades and accounts, no card | 7-day trial, payment method required |
| Price | $29.99/mo, everything included | $39/mo, or $75/mo with the AI coach |
New · Prop firm backtesting
Backtest under your prop firm's rules.
Replay real market history candle by candle and trade it like your challenge. Run the session under your own account's rules or any firm and program from our catalog: daily loss, max drawdown and the profit target are checked on every bar, and a breach ends the session the way it would end the real account.
- Two years of 1-minute history: futures (NQ, ES, YM, RTY, GC, SI, CL, NG, 6E and their micros), FX majors, gold and index CFDs.
- Market, limit and stop orders with stop loss, take profit, spread and commission, so the result is not a clean +1R.
- Up to four synced chart windows from 1 minute to monthly, drawing tools and SMC indicators: FVG, order blocks, BOS / CHoCH, sessions, fractals.
- Blind mode: a random start with the date hidden, so you trade the chart, not your memory of it.
Where Everedge is genuinely strong
The analysis layer is the best part of this product and deserves saying plainly.
Edge Discovery grading.
Grading setups A+ through D on statistical expectancy and tying recommended position size to the grade turns a journal into a decision tool. Few competitors attempt it.
Honest payout accounting.
Tracking what you actually withdrew, net of profit split, against what your attempts cost, gives a real ROI rather than the headline equity of a simulated account. Most journals ignore this entirely.
A deep AI layer.
Semantic search across your own journal, a coach that drafts write-ups, user-selectable models with per-token cost transparency, and an MCP connection so Claude can log trades directly.
Serious process tooling.
Trading plans, playbooks, session notes and daily, weekly and monthly report cards — a genuinely complete review loop.
Where Consistry fits prop trading better
02
Rules can only be enforced on live data
This is the structural consequence of CSV-only: nothing can warn you about a limit while the position is open, because the data arrives after the session. Consistry watches live equity, warns as a limit approaches, and checks the trade before you place it.
03
Firm rules that are verified and dated
20 firms and 26 programs read off the firms' own pages, re-checked weekly, each with a verification date. Everedge auto-populates rules for around ten named firms without publishing a total or specifying how trailing versus static drawdown is handled.
04
News windows are part of the rules
Each firm's news policy is verified alongside its drawdown limits and enforced before entry. Everedge has no news or economic-calendar feature at all.
05
Free to start, and a third of the price after that
Unlimited trades and accounts free without a card, then one $29.99/month plan. Everedge starts at $39, charges $75 for the AI coach tier, and its trial requires a payment method up front.
06
On your phone
Native iOS and Android apps with push alerts and a voice coach. Everedge's site does not mention mobile apps.
Who should pick which
Pick Everedge if: deep retrospective analysis is the point, you are happy exporting CSVs, and expectancy grading plus payout ROI accounting are worth $39 to $75 a month to you.
Pick Consistry if: you want trades to sync themselves, limits watched while positions are open, verified firm rules enforced before entry, and a free tier to start on.
FAQ
As of August 2026 mypropjournal.com issues a permanent redirect to everedge.ai. The Everedge site does not mention the My Prop Journal name, so whether this is a rebrand or a domain acquisition is not something either site states.
No. Their integrations page lists eleven platforms — TopstepX, ProjectX, Tradovate, NinjaTrader, Rithmic, Interactive Brokers, thinkorswim and others — and every one is a CSV export you upload yourself. Manual entry is the other option.
Because prop rules are live constraints. A daily loss limit or a trailing drawdown can be breached while a position is open; a journal that receives your trades after the session can analyze the breach but cannot warn you before it.
Yes. $29.99/month with everything included, against $39/month for Everedge's base plan and $75/month with its AI coach. Consistry also has a free tier with unlimited trades and accounts; Everedge requires a payment method for its 7-day trial.
Yes. Consistry's backtesting replays real market history bar by bar (two years of 1-minute data for major futures, FX pairs, gold and index CFDs) and runs the session under the rules of your own account or any firm and program in its catalog. Daily loss, max drawdown and the profit target are checked on every bar, a breach ends the session, and orders carry spread and commission. It runs on the web and is part of the Premium plan, with a 7-day free trial.
Analysis is better when the data arrives by itself
Start free — eight platforms syncing, verified firm rules, and a check before the trade rather than a report after it.